Here at The Royal German Shepherds we strongly feel that the FCI standard for the German Shepherd is the true guide for breeders who are truly interested in the Total German Shepherd dog.
The difference in American and European lines means that a top winning dog in the European style shows (SV) will not necessarily be any kind of a winner in an AKC show, and vise versa. So if you plan to participate in conformation shows with your German Shepherd dog, you need to decide which arena you will compete in and buy the appropriate dog.
In SV style shows, typically you get a critique of your dog by the judge after he has positioned the dogs. This is done at the end of each class.
It is a verbal critique, and every one hears it. This R.G.S. finds it very beneficial and as breeders, it allows them to see if they are breeding in the right sphere. This they feel would also be very beneficial in the AKC ring, as it would undoubtedly improve the GSD American lines. Another major difference between SV and AKC shows, is the placing of the dogs. Of course one is first, and one is last, but it really is the rating of the dog that truly matters.
In the SV ring your dog is placed in certain categories, and this depends on the age and whether your dog is Schutzhund titled or not. Males compete against males in the same age range, and the same is true for females.
You will not see a puppy compete against an adult dog. Your dog could finish 1st or 4th or 6th (depending on the size of the class), and still get a very good rating. The ratings are set by class, with dogs less than 1 year of age, competing for the rating of very promising (VP), promising (P) or less promising (LP).
For dogs between 1 year and 2 years of age or over 2 years without a working title, the ratings are very good (SG), Good (G), sufficient (A) or insufficient (M). For dogs over 2 years with a working title, the ratings are, excellent select (VA) (this title is only awarded in the Sieger show ), excellent (V), very good (SG), good (G), sufficient (A) or insufficient (M). Sometimes what separates the 1st from the 4th or 6th or further back is a only a slight or very minor fault, but that is up to the judge ( and remember when showing a dog, it is that judge's decision on that day). But the classification of a rating is certainly very important for a breeder, and really reflects the breed ability of his stock..